Skip to main content
Black Health logo Black Health
Policy

Title X's FY2027 funding notice moves the federal family-planning program toward fertility-awareness counseling. A 2022 study of the 2019 precedent shows what that looks like in practice.

Updated 6 min read

Editorial review

Reviewed by the Black Health editorial team against our editorial standards. Last updated . How we source.

Pexels / Polina Tankilevitch
Photo: Polina Tankilevitch

A peer-reviewed qualitative study of 55 Title X clinics in Arizona, Iowa, and Wisconsin during the 2020 implementation of the 2019 Protect Life Rule documented clinic withdrawal, patient cost exposure, and a pivot toward fertility-awareness methods over comprehensive contraceptive counseling. The FY2027 Notice of Funding Opportunity is on a similar trajectory. Title X client composition was about 22 percent Black...

A peer-reviewed qualitative study of 55 Title X clinics in Arizona, Iowa, and Wisconsin during the 2020 implementation of the 2019 Protect Life Rule documented clinic withdrawal, patient cost exposure, and a pivot toward fertility-awareness methods over comprehensive contraceptive counseling. The FY2027 Notice of Funding Opportunity is on a similar trajectory. Title X client composition was about 22 percent Black before the 2019 rule.
On this page

A 2022 qualitative study of 55 family planning facilities across Arizona, Iowa, and Wisconsin during the 2020 implementation of the 2019 Title X Protect Life Rule documented that clinics lost federal funding, passed costs to patients, restricted pregnancy-options counseling, and increased focus on fertility-awareness-based methods over comprehensive contraceptive counseling (VandeVusse et al., Sexual and Reproductive Health Matters 2022, PMID 35791904). The FY2027 Title X notice of funding opportunity from the HHS Office of Population Affairs (PA-FPH-27-001, applications due January 11, 2027) points the same way: it seeks strategies to "reduce overmedicalization by strengthening approaches focused on underlying behavioral and lifestyle factors of health and evidence-based practices such as fertility-awareness based methods," to "promote health and body literacy," to "advance reproductive goals counseling for all clients," and to "support family formation."

The 2019 precedent is the empirical record rather than a speculation. A FY2027 reframe along the same direction produces predictable on-the-ground effects: grantee withdrawal, narrowed counseling, and higher patient cost exposure concentrated in a client base that was about 22 percent Black before the 2019 rule took effect.

What the 2019 Title X Protect Life Rule did in practice

The VandeVusse team interviewed providers across 55 Title X-funded facilities in late 2020, capturing the rule's implementation window in the three states they studied. Four effects came out of the interviews.

First, clinics lost federal funding. Some Title X grantees, notably Planned Parenthood affiliates, withdrew rather than comply with the 2019 rule's gag provision on pregnancy-options counseling, and federal dollars redistributed to grantees that remained in the program. The net effect was a reduction in the active Title X clinic count from the pre-2019 baseline.

Second, clinics passed costs to patients. Facilities that remained in the program reported financial counseling workflows that introduced new paperwork and staff interactions, which in turn raised confidentiality concerns for patients who had previously received services with limited cost exposure.

Third, providers reported narrowing the counseling they could offer. Pregnancy-options counseling was restricted, and providers described concentrating on fertility-awareness-based methods as a substitute for the comprehensive contraceptive counseling that Title X had previously supported.

Fourth, adolescent confidentiality narrowed. Facilities reported increased pressure to involve parents or guardians in adolescent patients' care, which limited the confidential access that had previously been a Title X service feature.

The VandeVusse findings are qualitative and three-state. The peer-reviewed literature on 2019-rule-era Title X effects is sparse, and this study's findings inform the empirical baseline for what a FY2027 NOFO formalization of the same direction would produce at national scale.

The HIV prevention service-line gap this pivot compounds

A 2025 Frontiers in Reproductive Health study of Title X clinics in four Ending the HIV Epidemic priority jurisdictions in metro Atlanta documented that Title X-funded clinics are a federally funded access point for cisgender women, among whom Black women account for almost 60 percent of new HIV cases; the same clinics do not routinely provide pre-exposure prophylaxis as part of their services (Anderson et al., PMID 40964159). The Anderson team interviewed clinic staff and providers to identify implementation barriers for PrEP delivery in these safety-net settings. The underuse of the HIV-prevention service line is a pre-existing gap under the current Title X program. A FY2027 NOFO that narrows clinic scope toward fertility counseling is unlikely to expand the HIV-prevention service line, and the specific racial-equity mechanism is that Black cisgender women carry roughly 60 percent of the new HIV incidence the service gap falls on.

Community health centers and Title X clinics run a basic fertility workup, hormone labs and a pelvic exam, on a sliding scale that is often cheaper than a specialty fertility clinic visit. Our directory of free and charitable clinics lists centers by state. An at-home fertility hormone test is self-pay and is not billed to Medicaid, so the clinic workup usually costs less and catches more. If you want to start with an at-home test:

Sponsored

Everlywell

Check 5 hormones that affect your cycle and ovulation.

$149, FSA/HSA eligible

Order the fertility test

Who the FY2027 pivot would affect

In the Family Planning Annual Report from the HHS Office of Population Affairs, 861,707 of 3,939,749 Title X family planning users in 2018 were Black or African American, about 21.9 percent, and 632,409 of 2,772,387 in 2023, about 22.8 percent (our arithmetic from the report's table). Two structural factors mean a counseling-mix pivot disproportionately affects Black low-income women. First, Black women are overrepresented in the Title X-eligible income bracket relative to their share of the US population. Second, Title X clinics are a federally funded access point for HIV prevention services, where Anderson 2025 documented Black cisgender women's disproportionate share of new infections.

The county-level crossmap of Title X grantee geography against ACS majority-Black counties (50 percent or more Black per the 5-year estimates) would identify which specific counties lost coverage under the 2019 rule's Planned Parenthood withdrawal and predict which would lose coverage under FY2027. The Family Planning Annual Report and the ACS county data are both public, so that analysis can be done; we have not done it yet.

Named voices on the record

Dr. Melissa L. Kavanaugh, PhD, MPH, is a Principal Research Scientist at the Guttmacher Institute and senior author on the VandeVusse 2022 paper. Kavanaugh is the US researcher most closely associated with the peer-reviewed record on Title X policy effects. Institution: Guttmacher Institute.

Dr. Jessica M. Sales, PhD, is an Associate Professor at the Emory University Rollins School of Public Health and senior author on the Anderson 2025 paper. Sales is the named expert for the Title-X-as-HIV-prevention-access framing, distinct from Kavanaugh's contraception-access framing.

Neither has been interviewed for this piece. The citations above are the primary-source record under their respective institutional affiliations.

The 2019 Protect Life Rule faced federal legal challenges from state attorneys general, cities and family-planning organizations. The Ninth Circuit, sitting en banc, upheld the rule in February 2020; the Fourth Circuit, also en banc, held in September 2020 that it was arbitrary and capricious. The Supreme Court agreed in February 2021 to hear the consolidated cases (American Medical Association v. Cochran, Oregon v. Cochran, and Cochran v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore), then dismissed them on May 17, 2021 at the parties' request, and HHS replaced the rule with its 2021 Final Rule.

The procedural framing of the FY2027 NOFO matters for litigation prospects. A Notice of Funding Opportunity with priority-preference language carries less procedural friction than an Administrative Procedure Act-noticed rule. The distinction will determine whether the 2019 litigation playbook applies directly or whether a FY2027 challenge would have to argue a different procedural posture.

How to check whether your Title X clinic is still participating

The HHS Office of Population Affairs maintains a Title X Family Planning Clinic Locator at opa.hhs.gov. Under NOFO pivots, some grantees exit the program. The locator is the federal-source check on which clinics are currently active Title X grantees. Readers in a majority-Black county where the nearest Title X clinic is a Planned Parenthood affiliate should specifically check current participation, because the 2019 precedent is that Planned Parenthood affiliates withdrew rather than comply with the gag provision, and a FY2027 NOFO with similar provisions would likely produce a similar withdrawal pattern.

The Family Planning Annual Report from the HHS Office of Population Affairs, at opa.hhs.gov is where year-over-year grantee counts, clients served, and race and income breakdowns will eventually be measurable against any FY2027 changes. Readers tracking the program's trajectory can bookmark the FPAR page; the first report covering 2027 will be the first that can capture any early effects of the new funding cycle.

What we will add

We will update this piece when the FY2027 Title X awards are announced and when the Family Planning Annual Report shows the first data from the new grant cycle.

Corrections

  • : Figures and dates in policy explainers. What we changed
  • : Editing notes published as article text. What we changed

Read next

SNAP Work Rules 2026: Who Must Work and Who Is Exempt

Since July 4, 2025, SNAP's time limit covers adults ages 18 to 64 unless they have a child under 14 in their SNAP household or meet another exception. If it applies, you get 3 months of SNAP in 3 years unless you work, train or volunteer 80 hours a month. Veterans and people experiencing homelessness lost their exceptions. If you get a notice, ask for a fair hearing.

Continue reading

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider with questions about a medical condition.

Newsletter

One email a week with essential Black health guidance, plus a featured provider.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Was this helpful?

Your feedback shapes what we cover next.

Thanks for letting us know.

If you found this useful, sign up for our newsletter to get more like this.

Thanks. What was missing?

Optional. We read every response.

Thanks.

We use this to prioritize the next round of edits.

Follow Black Health for more

More from Zuri Carter

More in Policy