How Medicare rates them
- 5 stars 6
- 4 stars 5
- 3 stars 2
- 2 stars 4
- 1 star 6
23 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Sarasota
Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center
5 of 5 stars1959 N Honore Ave · (941) 379-3553
Ownership: For profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 45
- Staffing rating
- 5
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 5
- Average residents per day
- 37.4
Glenridge On Palmer Ranch Inc.
5 of 5 stars7333 Scotland Way · (941) 552-3603
Ownership: Non profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 61
- Staffing rating
- 5
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 5
- Average residents per day
- 50.4
Hawthorne Center For Rehab & Healing Of Sarasota
5 of 5 stars5381 Desoto Road · (941) 355-6111
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Summit Care
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 5
- Average residents per day
- 114.3
Pines Of Sarasota
5 of 5 stars1501 N Orange Ave · (941) 365-0250
Ownership: Non profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 171
- Staffing rating
- 4
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 4
- Average residents per day
- 192.7
Sarasota Memorial Nursing & Rehabilitation Center
5 of 5 stars5640 Rand Blvd · (941) 917-4950
Ownership: Non profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 5
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 4
- Average residents per day
- 102.5
Sunnyside Nursing Home
5 of 5 stars5201 Bahia Vista Street · (941) 371-2729
Ownership: Non profit - Church related
- Certified beds
- 60
- Staffing rating
- 5
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 4
- Average residents per day
- 52.3
Inn At Sarasota Bay Club
4 of 5 stars1303 North Tamiami Trail · (941) 953-6949
Ownership: For profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 44
- Staffing rating
- 5
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 3
- Average residents per day
- 25.7
Life Care Center Of Sarasota
4 of 5 stars8104 Tuttle Ave · (941) 360-6411
Ownership: For profit - Individual · Life Care Centers Of America
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 3
- Average residents per day
- 106.5
Plymouth Harbor Incorporated
4 of 5 stars700 John Ringling Blvd · (941) 365-2600
Ownership: Non profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 56
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 4
- Average residents per day
- 39.5
Pr Snf Operations Llc
4 of 5 stars5111 Palmer Ranch Parkway · (941) 926-7733
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company
- Certified beds
- 60
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 3
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 4
- Average residents per day
- 47.0
Sarasota Point Rehabilitation Center
4 of 5 stars2600 Courtland Street · (941) 952-9070
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Sovereign Healthcare Holdings
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 4
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 3
- Average residents per day
- 101.5
Bay Village Of Sarasota
3 of 5 stars8400 Vamo Road · (941) 966-5611
Ownership: Non profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 95
- Staffing rating
- 4
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 3
- Average residents per day
- 58.2
Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center
3 of 5 stars4602 Northgate Court · (941) 355-2913
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Simcha Hyman & Naftali Zanziper
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 4
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 3
- Average residents per day
- 89.9
Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center
2 of 5 stars3250 12th St · (941) 365-4185
Ownership: For profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 87
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 3
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 2
- Average residents per day
- 74.8
Creekside Health And Rehabilitation Center
2 of 5 stars5511 Swift Road · (941) 921-7462
Ownership: For profit - Corporation · Aston Health
- Certified beds
- 178
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 2
- Average residents per day
- 138.6
Harborview Sarasota
2 of 5 stars4783 Fruitville Road · (941) 378-8000
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Harborview Health Systems
- Certified beds
- 81
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 3
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 2
- Average residents per day
- 76.7
Springs At Lake Pointe Woods
2 of 5 stars3280 Lake Pointe Blvd · (941) 929-2700
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Summit Care
- Certified beds
- 101
- Staffing rating
- 2
- Quality measure rating
- 5
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 95.9
Aviata At Beneva
1 of 5 stars741 South Beneva Road · (941) 957-0310
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Aviata Health Group
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 3
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- Y
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 100.5
Aviata At Sarasota
1 of 5 stars1507 S Tuttle Ave · (941) 366-0336
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Aviata Health Group
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 2
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 109.9
Crescent Health And Rehabilitation Center
1 of 5 stars5401 Sawyer Rd · (941) 925-3427
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Aston Health
- Certified beds
- 140
- Staffing rating
- 2
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 105.6
Indian Beach Nursing And Rehab Center
1 of 5 stars1755 18th St · (941) 955-4915
Ownership: Non profit - Other · Eliyahu Mirlis
- Certified beds
- 101
- Staffing rating
- 4
- Quality measure rating
- 1
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- Y
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 95.9
Sarasota Health And Rehabilitation Center
1 of 5 stars1524 East Avenue South · (941) 365-2422
Ownership: Non profit - Other · Florida Institute For Long-Term Care
- Certified beds
- 144
- Staffing rating
- 4
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 128.5
Vivo Healthcare Meadows
1 of 5 stars5157 Park Club Drive · (941) 377-0022
Ownership: For profit - Limited Liability company · Vivo Healthcare
- Certified beds
- 120
- Staffing rating
- 2
- Quality measure rating
- 4
- Flagged by CMS for abuse
- N
- Health inspection rating
- 1
- Average residents per day
- 93.7
Common questions
How many nursing homes are there in Sarasota?
Medicare lists 23 certified nursing homes in Sarasota. 23 carry a CMS star rating and 11 are rated 4 or 5 stars.
What does the CMS star rating actually measure?
Medicare combines three things into one overall rating: state health inspection results, staffing levels reported from payroll data, and clinical quality measures. It is a federal rating, not our assessment, and a facility can be rated well on one and poorly on another.
Does Medicare or Medicaid pay for this?
Every facility listed here is Medicare-certified. What Medicare pays for and for how long depends on the type of care and your situation, so confirm coverage with the facility and with your plan before you commit.
Where this data comes from
Ratings and quality measures on this page come from CMS Care Compare, Nursing Home Provider Information, published August 2026. They are Medicare's assessments, not ours. We report the federal figures as published, with the file's own date, and we do not compute a score of our own or rank one facility against another.
CMS suppresses some measures for small facilities, so a blank is missing data rather than a poor result. Ratings are refreshed each quarter from the source file. Confirm anything that matters directly with the facility before you act on it.
Compiled and maintained by the Black Health editorial team. Found something wrong? Tell us and we will check it against the source.