Skip to main content
Black Health logo Black Health
Policy

Camara Phyllis Jones: The Three Levels of Racism, Defined

Updated 5 min read

Editorial review

Reviewed by the Black Health editorial team against our editorial standards. Last updated . How we source.

Dr. Camara Phyllis Jones, physician, epidemiologist, and past president of the American Public Health Association.
Photo: AaronShirley / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

In 2000, Dr. Camara Phyllis Jones published Levels of Racism: A Theoretic Framework and a Gardener's Tale in the American Journal of Public Health. The framework distinguishes institutional, personally mediated, and internalized racism, each with a distinct intervention pathway. It is one of the most-cited papers in public-health-equity scholarship of the last twenty-five years, and it sits underneath most of the disparity...

In 2000, Dr. Camara Phyllis Jones published Levels of Racism: A Theoretic Framework and a Gardener's Tale in the American Journal of Public Health. The framework distinguishes institutional, personally mediated, and internalized racism, each with a distinct intervention pathway. It is one of the most-cited papers in public-health-equity scholarship of the last twenty-five years, and it sits underneath most of the disparity numbers we cite on this site.
On this page

In 2000, Dr. Camara Phyllis Jones published a paper in the American Journal of Public Health that gave US public-health researchers and clinicians a vocabulary they did not previously have. The paper is called Levels of Racism: A Theoretic Framework and a Gardener's Tale, and it sits at PMID 10936998. It is short, plain, and one of the most-cited papers in public-health-equity scholarship of the last twenty-five years. If you have read anything in the racial-disparity literature in the last decade, the framework Jones laid out is probably underneath it, even when she is not cited by name.

The framework distinguishes three kinds of racism: institutional (the structure of who has access to what), personally mediated (individual prejudice, intentional or not), and internalized (the negative beliefs members of stigmatized groups absorb about themselves). The Gardener's Tale, the allegory she pairs with the framework, makes the institutional layer visible by walking through how a gardener with two flower boxes (one with rich soil, one with rocky soil) ends up explaining the height-of-flowers gap as something other than the soil.

That allegory is the part that gets quoted in policy testimony, training sessions, and op-eds. It is also the reason Jones's framework migrated from the academic literature into clinical training, public-health practice, and the structural-racism-and-health conversation that became national after 2020.

Who she is

Jones is a physician (Stanford MD) and an epidemiologist (Johns Hopkins MPH and PhD). She trained at Wellesley undergrad, taught at Harvard School of Public Health, worked at the CDC, and served as the 2015-2016 President of the American Public Health Association. She has served as a Senior Fellow at Morehouse School of Medicine and as an adjunct professor at Emory's Rollins School of Public Health. The career arc reads as the standard prestige path through US academic public health, with one important difference: she has spent the last three decades arguing, in technical-journal language and in lay-audience allegory, that racism is the structural variable the field had been trained to ignore.

The honors stack reflects that. Radcliffe Fellow at Harvard 2019-2020. Honorary Doctor of Science from Mount Sinai 2016. The John Snow Award in epidemiology, the field's prestige award named for the founder of modern public-health epidemiology, in 2011. APHA presidency, the largest US professional public-health body. The pattern is consistent: the establishment recognized the work even as the framework challenged the establishment.

What the framework says

The 2000 paper organizes racism into three operational layers, each with a distinct intervention pathway.

Institutional racism. Differential access to material resources, opportunities, and goods of society by race. The clearest examples in health: who gets cleaner air to breathe, who gets walkable neighborhoods, who gets a hospital with a stroke unit within twenty minutes, whose schools have working AC. None of this requires anyone to hold a personal prejudice. It is the system of who-got-what-where-and-when, codified in zoning, redlining, school district lines, hospital placement, and federal funding formulas.

Personally mediated racism. Prejudice (differential assumptions about the abilities, motives, and intents of others by race) and discrimination (differential actions on those assumptions). The clearest examples in health: the Hoffman 2016 PNAS pain-bias finding (PMID 27044069) that about half of the white medical students and residents surveyed endorsed at least one false belief about biological differences between Black and white people, and those who did rated a Black patient's pain lower and made less accurate treatment recommendations in mock cases. Personally mediated racism happens person-to-person; it does not require the institutional layer to be active, but it usually rides on top of it.

Internalized racism. Acceptance by members of stigmatized races of negative messages about their own abilities and intrinsic worth. In health, it can look like resignation: accepting worse care or worse health as what people like you should expect. Jones describes it as not believing in others who look like you, and not believing in yourself. Internalized racism is downstream of the other two; the intervention pathway is restoring trust, not lecturing patients.

Why this framework runs through our reporting

Most of the disparity numbers we cite on this site map onto the Jones framework directly. The 3.5x Black-white maternal mortality gap is institutional (which hospitals deliver Black babies, what their bundles of care look like) plus personally mediated (whose pain gets believed in the third trimester) plus internalized (women hesitating to escalate symptoms). The pulse-oximeter racial bias finding is institutional (which calibration cohorts the FDA accepted, which devices got cleared) plus personally mediated (clinicians not adjusting for the documented bias even after Sjoding 2020). The Black-physician-pipeline story is institutional all the way down.

Whatever brought you to this page, community health centers see patients regardless of insurance and charge on a sliding scale by income, reducing or waiving the fee for anyone who cannot pay. Our directory of free and charitable clinics lists centers by state. A same-day telehealth visit is self-pay and is not billed to Medicaid, so if you have Medicaid the clinic route will usually cost less. If you would rather see a clinician online today:

Sesame Care

See a doctor online today.

Same-day video visits from $34

See a doctor today

This is what the framework is for: making the disparity numbers parse not as a series of unconnected problems but as one structural pattern with multiple working layers. If you read more than a few articles on this site, you are already using the Jones framework whether you knew the name for it or not.

How to follow her work

The 2000 paper is open-access at PubMed Central; read it once, even if you have only ten minutes. PMID 10936998. Four pages, plain English, the framework you will see referenced everywhere else in the structural-racism-and-health literature.

Jones's 2014 TEDxEmory talk, Allegories on Race and Racism, shares four of her allegories on race and racism, the Gardener's Tale among them. It is on YouTube, freely available, and is the cleanest spoken-word version of the framework.

Her current public-facing institutional home is Morehouse School of Medicine's Satcher Health Leadership Institute as a Senior Fellow. The Institute publishes commentary, lectures, and policy briefs that extend the framework to current health-equity questions.

What you can take from this

Three concrete moves.

First, read the 2000 paper. It is the closest thing US public health has to a foundational text on race-and-health. The Gardener's Tale section in particular is worth knowing well; the next time you are in a conversation about a disparity number and someone reaches for a "but why" explanation, the framework gives you the structural answer.

Second, watch the TED talk. Twenty minutes. The Dual Reality allegory in particular is the one most readers find most useful for explaining race-and-health to friends and family who have not been in the public-health literature.

Third, the Jones framework is the lens you can carry into every clinical encounter. When something does not feel right in a clinic visit, the framework gives you three places to look (institutional, personally mediated, internalized) instead of one. That is more useful than any single piece of patient-advocacy advice we have written. Our directory is the practical companion when the next step is finding a different clinician.

Citations

Jones CP. Levels of racism: a theoretic framework and a gardener's tale. Am J Public Health. 2000;90(8):1212-1215. PMID 10936998. DOI 10.2105/ajph.90.8.1212.

Hoffman KM, Trawalter S, Axt JR, Oliver MN. Racial bias in pain assessment and treatment recommendations, and false beliefs about biological differences between blacks and whites. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2016;113(16):4296-4301. PMID 27044069.

American Public Health Association: Camara Phyllis Jones served as President, 2015-2016.

Satcher Health Leadership Institute, Morehouse School of Medicine. satcherinstitute.org.

Corrections

  • : Camara Jones: her degrees, her talk and one superlative. What we changed

Read next

SNAP Work Rules 2026: Who Must Work and Who Is Exempt

Since July 4, 2025, SNAP's time limit covers adults ages 18 to 64 unless they have a child under 14 in their SNAP household or meet another exception. If it applies, you get 3 months of SNAP in 3 years unless you work, train or volunteer 80 hours a month. Veterans and people experiencing homelessness lost their exceptions. If you get a notice, ask for a fair hearing.

Continue reading

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider with questions about a medical condition.

Newsletter

One email a week with essential Black health guidance, plus a featured provider.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Was this helpful?

Your feedback shapes what we cover next.

Thanks for letting us know.

If you found this useful, sign up for our newsletter to get more like this.

Thanks. What was missing?

Optional. We read every response.

Thanks.

We use this to prioritize the next round of edits.

Follow Black Health for more

More from Mark Jones

More in Policy